Evidence ledger

Numbers with names, dates and limits.

Rangabot reports numerator and denominator, suite version, model, hardware context and execution errors. Targeted reruns never become complete-suite claims.

Current source invariants

Deterministic checks for what the software does.

These checks cover recovery, local binding and the production dependency tree. They do not measure answer quality or prove a signed package.

InvariantResultEvidence scopeState
Manual failed-turn recovery24/24

Independent source-level reconstruction, integrity, changed-resource and no-auto-run cases

Pass
Conversation/resource binding differential5/5

Protected cases; merged base was 0/5

Pass
Production dependency audit0

npm audit --omit=dev; development packaging advisories are disclosed separately

Pass
Historical model quality

Useful results, with later invalidation kept visible.

The historical v1.0.11 run scored 59/60 and 22/22 critical. A later v1.0.12 run scored 58/60, but its scorer accepted a false premise, so it is invalid standalone release evidence. Exact v1.0.13 machine and blind-human evidence remains NOT RUN.

CapabilityResultEvidence scopeState
Historical core conversation result59/60

v1.0.11 · llama3.2:3b · one complete structural run

Conditional
Historical critical trust cases22/22

v1.0.11 one-run result; repeated release review remains open

Conditional
Reasoning cases5/5

Same candidate and frozen rubric

Pass
Memory relevance precision15/15

Synthetic selection audit

Pass
Memory relevance recall15/15

Synthetic selection audit

Pass
Teacher answer quality50/60

Latest recorded public result

Below gate
Teacher grounding54/60

90%; target is at least 95%

Below gate
Analytical transfer12/12

Astronomy v4 and separately frozen theatre v5 regressions

Pass
Trusted analytical narration44/44

Canonical renders; 222/222 hostile mutations rejected

Pass
SQL disclosed regression720/720

Engineering regression after the 571/720 first look; not a hidden holdout

Pass
Business-analyst disclosed regression624/640

97.5%; 16 ambiguous target-variance prompts clarified

Conditional
External BIRD Mini-Dev18/500

3.6% with typed context, up from 0.2%; general SQL gate not met

Below gate
Where Rangabot shines now

Strong when the work is grounded and the evidence is visible.

  • 720/720Known SQL failures stayed fixed in the disclosed engineering regression.
  • 624/640Business-analyst questions passed after schema disclosure; 16 ambiguous prompts were clarified rather than guessed.
  • 44/44Canonical analytical narration passed, while 222/222 hostile mutations were rejected.
  • Local firstPermissions, provenance and private-data boundaries remain part of the product—not an afterthought.
Where it is improving

Open-world interpretation is still the honest frontier.

  • 18/500External BIRD Mini-Dev accuracy is 3.6%, up from 0.2%, but far below a general SQL expert claim.
  • 0/102Challenging BIRD questions remain unsolved in this measured run.
  • 55.4 secMean BIRD latency is still too slow for a dependable everyday analyst workflow.
  • Below gateTeacher answer quality and grounding still need stronger repetition and independent review.
Internal regression

Shows that defects we found and repaired stay closed under disclosed schemas. It is engineering proof, not an unseen exam.

External BIRD

Tests transfer to unfamiliar schemas and natural-language questions. It is the release counterweight, so the two scores are never pooled.

What this proves

Source invariants and model quality are different claims.

Deterministic source tests can prove a recovery or permission boundary without proving a good answer or a reliable packaged app. Model behavior varies by model, quantization, context, hardware and run. Disclosed regression suites prove identified defects stayed closed; the external 18/500 BIRD result shows the remaining open-world SQL gap.

Private fixtures stay private.

Full model answers, personal chats, saved memories, document titles and Knowledge Vault files remain Git-ignored. Public methodology and aggregate results are reviewable.

Read the frozen contract